March Competition

Congratulations to Kevin Rucker, winner of the 11 Second Club March Competition! There were a ton of excellent entries this month, but Kevin's entry won over the voters with its subtle facial animation and solid read on the audio. We encourage everyone to check out all the great work that was done this month!

In recognition of his efforts, Kevin has won a professional AnimationMentor eCritique of his entry, recorded this month by Disney Supervising Animator Mike Belzer! Mike's been animating for over 20 years, on everything from "The Nightmare Before Christmas" and "Gumby" to "Dinosaur" and "Meet the Robinsons". Click here to watch his excellent critique of the winning entry!

March Winner eCritique!


Big thanks go to the 654 people who voted, and for the 2698 comments they left on the entries. It's great seeing so many people critiquing the entries, getting lots feedback is a great way to improve as an animator!

Congrats again to Kevin and all of the March competition participants!

Download the Audio Clip - Show Transcript

#1 - My Perfect Music
By: Kevin Rucker
7.1 Stars View this animation »
#2 - It's Unbelievable...
By: Andy Wakeley
6.93 Stars View this animation »
#3 - Rock and Roll Reality Show
By: W Jacob Gardner
6.78 Stars View this animation »
#4 - Perfect
By: Marco Palmieri
6.7 Stars View this animation »
#5 - My Music is Perfect
By: Roger
6.69 Stars View this animation »
#6 - Clefeus
By: Ridvan Cevik
6.63 Stars View this animation »
#7 - Waaa! My music was torn up!
By: Scott Douglas
6.38 Stars View this animation »
#8 - Music is my life
By: Anthony Travieso
6.3 Stars View this animation »
#9 - it's unbelievable!!
By: elvis martins
6.24 Stars View this animation »
#10 - The composer
By: Jomar Ravalo
6.19 Stars View this animation »
#11 - March08
By: Danny Southard
6.14 Stars View this animation »
#12 - Unbelieveble
By: Daniel Huertas
6.1 Stars View this animation »
#13 - Wolf visiting his Mom
By: Jacopo Armani
6.05 Stars View this animation »
#14 - etirwer
By:
5.96 Stars View this animation »
#15 - ReWrite
By: andrew hunt
5.91 Stars View this animation »
#16 - almost there
By: James Wilson
5.86 Stars View this animation »
#17 - Disappointment
By: Steve Brown
5.83 Stars View this animation »
#18 - Do Disturb
By: Daniel Harris
5.72 Stars View this animation »
#19 - Perfect As It Is!
By: Taran Matharu
5.67 Stars View this animation »
#20 - march 2008
By: pat hibulaire
5.6 Stars View this animation »
#21 - Pit fall of the fresher
By: JubyJose
5.53 Stars View this animation »
#22 - Perfect as it is
By: Federico Abib
5.51 Stars View this animation »
#23 - I can't ...rewrite...
By: Justin Lashley
5.5 Stars View this animation »
#24 - musician
By: kubilay kocaoglu
5.49 Stars View this animation »
#25 - My Music Puff
By: Süleyman Gürgün
5.48 Stars View this animation »
#26 - nobody`s perfect
By: Tomas Vega
5.42 Stars View this animation »
#27 - march 2008 entry
By: hongman
5.38 Stars View this animation »
#28 - unbelievable
By: mark whitcombe
5.33 Stars View this animation »
#29 - I want to confess...
By: Winnie . S
5.31 Stars View this animation »
#30 - Its Never Perfect
By: Chris Tan
5.25 Stars View this animation »
#31 - i'm emotional!
By: vince gorman
5.24 Stars View this animation »
#32 - Perfect Music
By: Guilherme Trog
5.23 Stars View this animation »
#33 - I Kill You...
By: Alan Starship
5.21 Stars View this animation »
#34 - Disappointed Guy
By: Vinay Acharya
5.16 Stars View this animation »
#34 - Alien Astronaut
By: Alan Camilo
5.16 Stars View this animation »
#36 - The unhappy robot.
By: Jose Maria Ravalo
5.1 Stars View this animation »
#36 - flawless
By: gergely kali
5.1 Stars View this animation »
#36 - Drama
By: Jude B
5.1 Stars View this animation »
#39 - I'm Mozart !
By: TY
5.09 Stars View this animation »
#40 - Unfair
By: Miran Dilberovic
5.06 Stars View this animation »
#41 - Unhappy Chappy
By: Dave Edwardz
4.96 Stars View this animation »
#42 - torn up!
By: andrew keeble
4.95 Stars View this animation »
#43 - Unbelievable
By: Luke Burnet
4.91 Stars View this animation »
#44 - But Its Perfect as it is!
By: Ezra Allen
4.84 Stars View this animation »
#44 - Fustrated Artist
By: Carlos Fins
4.84 Stars View this animation »
#46 - Feathered and Flawed
By: Brad Bradbury
4.83 Stars View this animation »
#47 - Elvis
By: Yogesh Kaushal
4.82 Stars View this animation »
#48 - Can't re-write whats perfect
By: Nate Lane
4.75 Stars View this animation »
#49 - It's unbelievable.
By: chrisbyk
4.72 Stars View this animation »
#50 - Frustrated Composer
By: Gideon Caspi
4.7 Stars View this animation »
#51 - Moe Zart Surprise
By: Julien Abenhaim
4.66 Stars View this animation »
#51 - The Ultimate Shutdown
By: Avner Engel
4.66 Stars View this animation »
#53 - But it's perfect as it is
By: Arthur Metcalf
4.64 Stars View this animation »
#53 - When a man loves his music.
By: Steve C
4.64 Stars View this animation »
#53 - Metro Music
By: Tomas Jech
4.64 Stars View this animation »
#56 - The Perfect Score
By: Andrew Farrell
4.59 Stars View this animation »
#57 - But it's perfect
By: DIEGO COLLELL
4.58 Stars View this animation »
#58 - I hate that director...
By: Tony Mecca
4.55 Stars View this animation »
#59 - The unbelievable final animation
By: Jean-Luc Delhougne
4.53 Stars View this animation »
#60 - Hopelessness . . .
By: Sergey B.
4.51 Stars View this animation »
#61 - Backstage Dilemna
By: Vahram Antonian
4.49 Stars View this animation »
#62 - un believable
By: peter adams
4.47 Stars View this animation »
#63 - I've been cut short
By: Greg Wark
4.43 Stars View this animation »
#64 - Sacked.
By: Brad Kinley
4.41 Stars View this animation »
#66 - Perfect Music
By: Jafar
4.32 Stars View this animation »
#67 - Stranger in a bus
By: Reano
4.31 Stars View this animation »
#68 - Perfect Music
By: c_ku2001
4.3 Stars View this animation »
#69 - "But it's perfect as it is"
By: Arron Westley
4.27 Stars View this animation »
#70 - frustration
By: sharad kumar
4.26 Stars View this animation »
#71 - Don't talk to the monkey...
By: Nick Hales
4.25 Stars View this animation »
#72 - Unbelievable Schubert!
By:
4.24 Stars View this animation »
#73 - perfect music
By: David Ward
4.23 Stars View this animation »
#74 - Unbelivable!
By: John B
4.22 Stars View this animation »
#74 - Animator
By: Simon Hung
4.22 Stars View this animation »
#74 - Mozart
By: David Andrade
4.22 Stars View this animation »
#74 - El Afina Maracas
By: German U.
4.22 Stars View this animation »
#78 - It's not perfect...
By: Eric Huang
4.21 Stars View this animation »
#79 - Perfect...
By: Tom Law
4.2 Stars View this animation »
#80 - Maestro
By: Kensaba
4.17 Stars View this animation »
#81 - I can' t
By: Giuseppe
4.16 Stars View this animation »
#82 - perfect music
By: Kenny
4.12 Stars View this animation »
#83 - Perfect Ego
By: Louis Ng
4.04 Stars View this animation »
#84 - Unbelievable!
By: Jimmy Wu
3.97 Stars View this animation »
#85 - The Musician
By: Arindam
3.96 Stars View this animation »
#86 - Music!
By: Sarah Ricketts
3.94 Stars View this animation »
#86 - Perfect Music
By: Chris Moss
3.94 Stars View this animation »
#88 - The Director
By: Adriano Mariotto
3.92 Stars View this animation »
#89 - The Melodist and his Music
By: Lisa Tyler
3.91 Stars View this animation »
#90 - March 11 Second Club
By: Robert Diaz
3.89 Stars View this animation »
#91 - Punk Singer
By: Ronaldo Brito
3.82 Stars View this animation »
#92 - 60's
By: Hisato Tokumaru
3.81 Stars View this animation »
#93 - Amadeus Ain't Playin'. Ya know?
By: Drew Current
3.75 Stars View this animation »
#94 - artists love
By: Kim Allen
3.72 Stars View this animation »
#95 - I Can't...
By: Emmanuel
3.71 Stars View this animation »
#96 - Lithiumless
By: Lawrence Tan
3.7 Stars View this animation »
#97 - Unbelievable
By: Dhar Jabouri
3.65 Stars View this animation »
#98 - it's perfect !!
By: Bussaba Techasrisutee
3.64 Stars View this animation »
#99 - Perfect
By: Joey Ravioli
3.63 Stars View this animation »
#100 - Overunbelievable
By: Kai Huai
3.59 Stars View this animation »
#101 - What's Perfect
By: Frank Abney
3.58 Stars View this animation »
#102 - Amadeus
By: Nick Knudson
3.57 Stars View this animation »
#102 - JABÁ!
By: Thiago Calssado
3.57 Stars View this animation »
#104 - perfect
By: bigesh tp
3.56 Stars View this animation »
#105 - bad director
By: Lukasz Kopec
3.54 Stars View this animation »
#106 - What's perfect..
By: David Lochhead
3.51 Stars View this animation »
#107 - unbelievable
By: Paulo Cesar Biajante
3.49 Stars View this animation »
#108 - GAJJOSH_R.S.Joshi
By: Rushikesh Joshi
3.44 Stars View this animation »
#109 - hard to believe...!!
By: sushant gupta
3.4 Stars View this animation »
#110 - Can't believe it!
By: Jarred de Beer
3.36 Stars View this animation »
#111 - the lament
By: Jeremie Rosner
3.35 Stars View this animation »
#112 - But it's perfect!
By: Pete Shand
3.34 Stars View this animation »
#112 - I cant rewrite
By: Ethan Reitz
3.34 Stars View this animation »
#114 - Torn up my director!!
By: Shogna Chang
3.27 Stars View this animation »
#115 - ^_^
By: HIM CHAN
3.25 Stars View this animation »
#116 - It's perfect as it is...
By: Ryan D Lowe
3.21 Stars View this animation »
#117 - EmoBoy
By: Steve
3.19 Stars View this animation »
#118 - Composer can't believe it
By: Christoffer Andersen
3.18 Stars View this animation »
#119 - It's Unbelievable!!!
By: James G. Petropoulos
3.12 Stars View this animation »
#120 - Plea to the Producers
By: Brad Wright
3.11 Stars View this animation »
#121 - anxious
By: rushang
3.08 Stars View this animation »
#122 - Frustrated musician
By: Renato Fochi
3.03 Stars View this animation »
#123 - rewrite whats perfect!
By: prashant rawal
3.02 Stars View this animation »
#123 - the perfect writer
By: Bilal Ahmad
3.02 Stars View this animation »
#125 - Rewrite!!
By: RaymondNg
2.97 Stars View this animation »
#126 - Unbelievable
By: Michel Giguère
2.95 Stars View this animation »
#127 - ciceto wolfy
By: notapix-youtube
2.92 Stars View this animation »
#128 - guitar zero
By: Tommy
2.86 Stars View this animation »
#129 - Punk Composer
By: Matt Hubel
2.8 Stars View this animation »
#130 - Perfection Has it's Price
By: Jason Smith
2.78 Stars View this animation »
#131 - Perfect
By: Anthony Lynch
2.75 Stars View this animation »
#132 - Awakening
By: Jose Francisco Tarallo
2.66 Stars View this animation »
#132 - Snakes on boats
By: Dennis Jensen
2.66 Stars View this animation »
#134 - Director's Call
By: Brad Regier
2.61 Stars View this animation »
#135 - cut
By: Dragos Ungureanu
2.58 Stars View this animation »
#135 - A Mid-days Reflection on Life
By: Brady Ritz
2.58 Stars View this animation »
#135 - Depressed Musician
By: Kuo Chung-kang
2.58 Stars View this animation »
#138 - March 08 Unbelivable
By: Charles Blouin
2.5 Stars View this animation »
#139 - I can't... rewrite what's perfec
By: Niko
2.48 Stars View this animation »
#140 - It's Perfect As It Is
By: Alec Sinanoski
2.37 Stars View this animation »
#141 - 11 second rant
By: Destinee Cleveland
2.3 Stars View this animation »
#142 - amadeus
By: dan tran
2.25 Stars View this animation »
#142 - stand alone
By: eleazermunoz
2.25 Stars View this animation »
#144 - Torn Up
By: Gary Foster
2.21 Stars View this animation »
#145 - March 2008 Entry
By: Mike Courtney
1.89 Stars View this animation »
#146 - a bug's lament
By: richard fox
1.87 Stars View this animation »
#147 - Perfect as it is?
By: Rory
1.86 Stars View this animation »
#148 - what is perfect
By: Tom Steiner
1.63 Stars View this animation »