Final Rating: 5.18. Finished 42 out of 206 entries.

687 views including the voting period.


Animator: Amartya Mukherji

Description: Story : An alien tribe, trying to justify and convince others, - that there is life in the globe, that he has found.

Expressions and story was not clear in playblast. I wish I had more time to polish my character animation further.

Experience: 5 years

Time taken: didn't get enough time this month


(Commenting only available during the rating period)

Amartya Mukherji:

The expressions and storyline were not clearly readable in playblast, so I ran out of time for animation polishing.
Anyways, I will refine my animation, keeping your valuable feedback and suggestions in mind.

James Trimm:

great body animation- is there any way to push his face/ expressions more with the rig you're using?

Robert Huffmon:

Lip sync could use some work, but besides that nice job!

Paula Decanini:

Looks nice, but the lip sync needs a lot of work.

ben malberg:

Beautiful render and models. Um as for the animation it looks like his right arm is floating in IK, I would record some video reference and analyze how the arm moves in conjunction with the body, then block those movements out. The face looks a bit stiff, as does the mouth animation. Great idea with the aliens.

Steve Schwartz:

Would really go over that lip sync again.

Nicholas Steeves:

Lip syncing needs some improvement

Evelyn Hernandez:

i like the strong expression. I would probably take the time to keep animating to sync with the dialogue

Joyce Makker:

Felt like you were lazy on the lipsync and prioritized everything else, because the rest is really good, but the lipsync is awful.

Peter Meindertsma:

i gave this one a 9, i think you could really do with a bit more enunciation with the dialogue in some parts of it. It looks great and i like the acting in it. with some more time spent on the lip sinc i would give this a 10.

Brent Forrest:

What is this alien Ceaser? Nice compositing. Good style. Aniamtion is good, not excellent. But, you pulled off the subtlety well which most people can't do. 8 stars.

Sandra Tapia:

Nice render. I love the colors you used for the characters. It probably needs a little more work on lip sync.


shuttle acting is not always floaty..punch in timing is needed

Tobias Fuhr:

i like it, but you have a little mouth movements, almost invisible.


Lipsync needs more work