I thought!
Comments:
(Commenting only available during the rating period)
Marcos Borba Moreira:
good body expression
Aaron Clement:
He almost seems too happy at the end. I felt too many gestures were being used... felt cliche at times... The timing felt good.
Daniel Shorten:
I like that he doesn't have to rub his nose when he sniffs, and that he ends assertively with his eyes up.
Eddie Chew:
some nice poses....seems abit jerky in some transitions....perhaps smooth out some of the curves in the head movements
Eric Huang:
Not bad :)
Steve Clarke:
Not quite sure what it is about this, I like the gestures and timing, but something doesnt quite work in places. The moves seem a little forced i think and need to be more natural. Sorry if thats vague.
Josh Doohen:
good motion. did that kid get beat up?
W Jacob Gardner:
is there a reason for the diploma on the wall? does that give any context to the scene?
Tom Cho:
The eyes seem to lack any life.
John Erickson:
some good poses and timing. the lip synch looks a bit off. good job overall
Wolfram Kampffmeyer:
Movement not smooth, did you animate on 2s? smooth your curves! Nice poses though
Stuart Livingston:
That's a great pose at "this girl that he loves" I wouldnt have thought of that but it works. Decent posing, but could've used a render, as you may agree
selvaraj:
good animation
Teju Aloysius:
good and unique acting poses. looks cool.
Henning Koczy:
REally good. Up til the last pose... turns floaty... end on a punch.
Mike Courtney:
lip sync needs some work









Animator: myung lee
Description: my october animation! enjoy~
comments and crits always welcome
Experience: 2 yrs
Time taken: 1 week off and on