Aparna Varma:

love the kid!! absolutely,love the kid!

nice expressions...

C. J. Cow:

this is too funny lolol

manlio vetri:

lolol funny

luv2animate:

gr8 one!!ohh..dad is very pissed off!!!

Ethan Cooksmith:

this one was great...good emotions and reactions on both the characters...would have rated higher if the lip sync was better. it was off at "he has a gift, and once you"

Amdbcg:

good animation there :D
I think there should be a little more follow through action, but that's just me :)

Felipe Castanhari:

Great animation

Congratulations

Matt Hirengen:

good job.

Juan Pablo:

nice

alan:

i love the animation on the grab on the son. one thing i did notice is the right arm is kind of stiff but i'm just being picky. awesome arcs and funny scene, overall, excellent work.

Alex Crouch:

Great looking piece, very well animated, very professional looking. I have a little trouble understanding what the story is, though. I'm not sure why Dad grabs the kid or why he seems so agitated.

Daniel Morgan Walsh:

The part where he says the second "gift" and "if you acknowledge that" seemed off. However the body animation was very good and the animation of the child was brilliant. Good Job.

David Higgins:

Very theatrical but I liked it.

Srujith kumar Ogirala:

conept is good. you need to work on animation.

Erik Griott:

ok, interesting. i think the only thing this lacks is story. we don't know what the father's motivation is, and we don't know why he treats his son like a rag doll.

John Seldon:

thats cool but there doesnt seem to be much weight shifting in the father when hes moving. his pelvis doesnt move as much as it should be i think. its nice stuff tho!

Martin Silfvast:

scary dad :-)

Barnabas Boehler:

This is pretty good. I might add a bit of overshoot into Bishops' poses because he hits some a bit hard. Also, the kid seems to hang in the there for a few frames too long after his father lets go.

rajeshk:

nice ..very nice like the staging .. arcs..acting ..animation very good....

And u kept the BG dark .. Tht helps to read the animation better ( Although ur animation is very good ,,. but i think that helps..)

And u just caught the precise " high point" (from Frame 165 to 189) on ur animation..(these 25 frames made u winner)..like the way u kept the entire scene.. very balanced with good contrast in ur poses .. great.. loved it..

Nancy:

Wow, it is so great, I like it

Carol Cheng:

i liked the boy swinging in the air~

Ryan Shannon:

The child is animated great. i think there is a little stiffness is the father, hands especially. Overall, this is really good though.

Brad Regier:

Fun shot here!
When the kid falls, maybe he could fall faster but his arm could stretch and his hand lags behind a few frames and then the hand snaps down...
Good job!

Paul Fuller:

Nice animation. I think the sweep between frame 80-100 has a nice arc, but the motion stops suddenly when the pose is hit. I also think the kid falling in the end is timed really well. Good job.

shruti:

lol!! interesting

Frank G:

Great opening pose. Nice arcs. Stars, stars, stars.

Chad Swanson:

Great Job I love it!

asif:

hahahaha really liked the way he pulls his son i laughed on it hehehehehe, good work. just felt like lipsync was off at very few places. Good luck.

Romain Digonnet:

Very nice animation, and good acting choices...

The lipsinc is a bit off during the first 200 frames.

Mark Homoky:

Very nicely executed. Well thought out and the son's movements don't distract from the main character (the father) speaking in the piece. Well done, and good luck! I predict a winner?!