Hernán Bruna:

this one man... deserves to win, the animation could be better but the whole escene is insane ;)

Felipe:

nice render o.O

andyM:

your feet look a bit sticky, i really like the turn at 260. very cinematic

sunil:

wow awesome work

John Paul Canepa:

Very realistic animation, wow!

Michael Mahy:

absolutely brilliant. I hope I win, but you can be close second. :)

Renato Fochi:

Amazing animation ans story!!

Patrick O'Brien:

Wow! this is movie quality work. You must have worked in the field for a while to get this kind of quality.

Michael Carter:

loved the body language but the facial animation was overacted just a little bit.

Karin Rindevall:

Wow, love this one. The movements look so realistic and natural. To me, that is the hardest part of animation. Impressive!

Fernando Herrera:

Looks very good. Could use more polishing though. I wish you spent less time on rendering, hair and effects.

Jeff Simon:

wow

Kevin:

It looks great. Could have used more acting.

Bob Yang:

nice story
nice body and facial animating
I can even feel the charactor
I guess you'll be winner
you deserve the full mark
I love the detail of the man behaved disappoint and sad when he knee on the ground and found the man was dead.

Nanda van Dijk:

I love your animation, the libsinq is perfect and the rest looks realy great. the only critique i have is that i dont like the animation switch on the guy at the end. it feels stange. the emotion at the end is good but he goes to quickly from happy to frustrated. but very good animation. great job!!!

Batuhan Özer:

great job. ambiance, acting, camera they all works good together. really like it

Álvaro González:

I'll really never wash my eyes again!

Clym:

WOW really nice rendering and walk animations!!! love the flow of the hair also...very good

Andreas Leoutsarakos:

Pretty render, but I would have liked to have seen you put more effort in their animation while they're speaking then those 10 seconds of build up.

yizhack jacobs:

wahoo
exept for the hand movmant
you can see its a good animation from the first frame

Ethan Cooksmith:

absolutely beautiful, i can really feel their thoughts and emotions in this one.
only issue i see is the creep, there is no weight in it

Chase Shields:

very nice acting...!!

Andy Cunial:

the level on polish on this is amazing.

Jason Smith:

Awesome job! Very nice expressions, poses, staging, and lighting! Great job!

Matthieu Delaere:

Really good expressions! But you have a dead pose in the beginning. Try to get loose of it! But great stuff!!!

Shane Collins:

great scene and animation, could be a little more expressive with poses and snappier. great stuff

Kymer:

Awesome, I really loved the acting. Nice and subtle. One of my faves (:

Pablo Perez:

Hi! the rig looks so good, an the render is awesome, congrats!

Johnny Tesoro:

I love the cuts, I love the acting. Very cinematic and the last look of the character in the last shot is golden! Nice subtleties here!

Darrell:

Great scene!! I love the sneaking into the scene... and the render is great!! Awesome job!!!

abhijit:

Great work, Good Luck

Robert Diaz:

Very cool scene. The key point I want to make is that your animation is solid. A lot of people are going to be distracted about how cool the other stuff you did was (cloth/hair). But its for nothing if the animation wasn't there. Good stuff.

Oh, and the rig your using has wrinkles that show on the face/forehead. That adds a lot of subtlty. I wish I had access to that rig.

Tom Long:

man, hair and averything, nice work definate contender.

Christiaan Moleman:

I like the naturalistic feel of the animation but maybe you could have used a few less close-ups, maybe throw in a medium shot at the end...

Dionysis Douliakas:

Very expressive! It's easy to get into the feeling of these characters!

Stephanie Traska:

Wow, I think your only flaw is the lips missing a few phonemes. Looks movie-quality!

deepak:

wow!!!!! how long did it take u ? feels like watchin a short. i didnt see any blinks on the kneeling character.

Daniel Bystedt:

Good staging and minimalistic acting.

Kent Wong:

very good emotion, good acting and story telling. I like it.
Overall nice detailed animation, nice facial. I love it. Great job man. Hi-stars from me. =)