I thought!!
Comments:
(Commenting only available during the rating period)
Jack Daniels:
Lip sync seems off and the wrist is broken in the last pose. Otherwise, a very nice piece.
Gustavo dos Santos Souto:
Nice, but needs to be more natural.
Jesse Baumgartner:
His lip sync could use a lot of work. You have some nice poses going on but the timing is real even throughout.
John Erickson:
Timing is a bit off with the poses and lip synching. i like the face wipe towards the end. at 'This girl that he loves' the timing of the poses seem a bit late. good overall.
Aaron Jonas:
good start. needs a little work
Matt Garward:
Well animated, but a few too many pose ideas going on, especially with the left hand. At 48 the left hand touches his face for about 8 frames, it briefly touches the table about 4 times, the face wipe is nice, but you've previously had him touch his temple with that hand... just streamline some of those ideas and you'll have less hand-waving and a stronger, more meaningful performance. :)
diganta:
its ealy good but take care of the last part
Gill Frank:
dont really get the action with the sound. Need more strong poses and exspretion, I think that would help the acting better. But still well done. :)
Gregory Naud:
Try to make more powerful change on strong accent in the dialogue. It will help to make the animation more beleivable.
David Artura:
Overall it's a pretty solid effort, but the lip sync is slow in a lot of parts. I'm not too sure how forgiving the rig is with the lip controls, but they could be pushed more.
Nate Dorn:
looks good so far
Aaron Clement:
Needs more moving holds... things don't stop moving... The shoulder shrug was good.
John Cruz:
I like. Not a whole lot for me to say.
Giovanni:
I like it, even if perhaps it is a little bit "overplayed" (too much exaggeration in facial expressions)
Mike Courtney:
lip sync needs work
Yeray Díaz Díaz:
You have to watch your timing, I really like your poses but they're really off the clip.
Christiaan Moleman:
Hands are little too overlappy on "I thought"... "help him" gesture is really nice. The timing doesn't feel right on "things would change for me".
Jorge Rodiles:
needs more exageraton, and anticipation on the face expressions, and more timing int eh body language









Animator: Eun Ki
Description: He realizes it's hopeless trying to help his friend...
Experience: Nothing much
Time taken: Almost 10 days..