Gill Frank:

LOL!!! on I will give you good for this one, but animation whise I cant comment.
Nice Idea do. :)

Mark Bogdanoff:

Great animation, but not character animation.

Michael Twentyman:

interesting motion design, but isn't this about character acting?

Guillaume Roux:

nice to see something different
It works visualy good rythme

Mariya Kalachova:

Cool design but I wasn't aware that this site was for anything but character animation.. sorry but as good as it is I can't really give a good mark compared to all the people who made the effort to animate a difficult character with emotion and physics.

Jeranimo:

I thought this is a character animation contest! :|

Frank Collazo:

interesting idea

Nick Adducci:

I suppose this has some "character" animation in it, and I find that kinda funny but not a winning piece.

Renaud Déchaux:

Wahou, i don't know why you did that, but, in one sens, it's good, it's animation, and it's fun.
Maybe you could add others stuff for make your scene more interesting, but it's original.
It's hard to vote for this scene, it's so different!

beck veitch:

I really like the timing on this animation and it works well with the dialog, however I think more could have done with the typography design.

Tim Kings-Lynne:

great idea

more could be done with typo-graphical elements rather than just text

i love the idea, jsut wanted to see it pushed to its full potential

Rico Lim:

sorry. not motion graphics animation contest

Paul Naas:

Very clever! Made me laugh!

Louis Ng:

erm . .what is this?

Johnny Castuciano:

hey this is really cool design, and leads the eye well. neat-o

Brent Steinberg:

that was unexpected! but you know what, i liked it. there was a lot of spunk to it. nice job.

Charles Eubanks:

I feel a little bad rating this submission low, because you really did do a good job timing your text animation to match the dialog. However, this is a character animation contest, and there was no character performance in your submission.

Kamal Bhattacharjee:

really nice break through.....
but expecting character!!
Good job dude...........
Good job dude...........

andrea:

so nice! well done

Ian John White:

Could be done very easily and does not show an awful lot of skill.

Ritwik Nag:

nice bit of text animation....

benj:

I don t know how to rate this...
it s great but it s not the kind of animation that we re supposed to see... it s more a graphic animation so...

Yeray Díaz Díaz:

WOW!!! Talk about a fresh approach! Congratulations on the animation looks really nice. There's no character thuogh so I guess you're not competing with the rest. Still, nice job ;)

Traci Plagmann:

Nice use of the type with the audio. It doesn't really fit the idea of character animation though.

Jor:

Hm, your text has good movement and is actually pretty awesome in terms of illustrating the audio, but I think it would infinitely better if you had a character acting it out.

Guilherme Trog:

Can anyone explain me what is IT?

Caleb Drewel:

ummmm..... yea, but yea... no

Ken Rice:

Fun interesting stuff.

John Vassallo:

I think this is a character animation competition...Despite that, its just black and white text.

Dan Dulberger:

Unexpected. But nice change with abit more abstract animation inbetween all the ca. It was nicely done but nothing special. Can't really give it a fair rating.

Niels Beekes:

hm, acting with words, heck why not!

Eileen Kearney:

It's creative, but I don't know how to rate this...

gary hsu:

weird, I can feel the emotion in the text animation, heheh, it would be better if Robin William's part is in different color though

Brian Nicolucci:

Haha, brilliant take on the audio!

jonathan topf:

?

Yem Xnake Yu:

it's surprising,but i can't give you high score. coz there is too less character animation in this short

Siva Kumar:

You threw a surprise !!!

Craig Perez:

nice concept good acting through the cutting/movements and font

Aaron Clement:

Haha... I think this is the first time I've ever seen some one enter a clip with no character in it... I'll give you points for originality... it's animation... but not character animation.

Santi Hurtado:

I thought this was a character animation thing.
I don't know how this can get to the submitions...

danyeal:

hm.. i mean looks cool, but

David Meyers:

hahaha,
nice take on this one. I totally wasnt expecting that.

J Saunders:

fun stuff... not realy character. would have been cool if you changed the color of the text that says "i made you short?"

Rob:

LOL..An interesting take...I think it works well for what it is...

Dave:

nice idea

Justin Weg:

cute idea

Damodar V Sawant:

I guess ! its Character animation contest ..............

Taber Dunipace:

It's nice and all but I really don't know anything about graphic design.

Jamie:

What is this?

cecile:

déja vu

David Trudel:

No character... where is the acting?

Joyce Tan:

funny

Gustavo dos Santos Souto:

It's character animation, not lettering my friend....

Regis Le Roy:

good idea, reminds me on the pulpfiction typographic animation

Amy:

It's nice to see words with emotions. I don't think I've ever seen that here before. I'd still like a better explanation at the end as to why the words scream at the phrase "i made you short."

Kristoffer Clark:

nice take on the audio clip

Matt Kenley:

I dont really now how to rate this one because I think this is supposed to be a character animation competition. But ill give it a grade anyway

Dave Blanchette:

unexpected, but interesting

Dan Harriman:

A novel idea. But isn't this supposed to be a character animation site?

M.Bell:

Cool stuff.... but this isn't a motion graphics website/forum. Character animation PLEASE....

Andrew Linke:

I really really liked this one, a very different spin on things.

Renn:

Not a bad idea, just not the right place for it I think...