March Competition

Congratulations to Kevin Rucker, winner of the 11 Second Club March Competition! There were a ton of excellent entries this month, but Kevin's entry won over the voters with its subtle facial animation and solid read on the audio. We encourage everyone to check out all the great work that was done this month!

In recognition of his efforts, Kevin has won a professional AnimationMentor eCritique of his entry, recorded this month by Disney Supervising Animator Mike Belzer! Mike's been animating for over 20 years, on everything from "The Nightmare Before Christmas" and "Gumby" to "Dinosaur" and "Meet the Robinsons". Click here to watch his excellent critique of the winning entry!

March Winner eCritique!


Big thanks go to the 654 people who voted, and for the 2698 comments they left on the entries. It's great seeing so many people critiquing the entries, getting lots feedback is a great way to improve as an animator!

Congrats again to Kevin and all of the March competition participants!

Download the Audio Clip

#1 - Kevin Rucker My Perfect Music 7.1 Stars

#2 - Andy Wakeley It's Unbelievable... 6.93 Stars

#3 - W Jacob Gardner Rock and Roll Reality Show 6.78 Stars

#4 - Marco Palmieri Perfect 6.7 Stars

#5 - Roger My Music is Perfect 6.69 Stars

#6 - Ridvan Cevik Clefeus 6.63 Stars

#7 - Scott Douglas Waaa! My music was torn up! 6.38 Stars

#8 - Anthony Travieso Music is my life 6.3 Stars

#9 - elvis martins it's unbelievable!! 6.24 Stars

#10 - Jomar Ravalo The composer 6.19 Stars

#11 - Danny Southard March08 6.14 Stars

#12 - Daniel Huertas Unbelieveble 6.1 Stars

#13 - Jacopo Armani Wolf visiting his Mom 6.05 Stars

#14 - Alex Fundora etirwer 5.96 Stars

#15 - andrew hunt ReWrite 5.91 Stars

#16 - James Wilson almost there 5.86 Stars

#17 - Steve Brown Disappointment 5.83 Stars

#18 - Daniel Harris Do Disturb 5.72 Stars

#19 - Taran Matharu Perfect As It Is! 5.67 Stars

#20 - pat hibulaire march 2008 5.6 Stars

#21 - JubyJose Pit fall of the fresher 5.53 Stars

#22 - Federico Abib Perfect as it is 5.51 Stars

#23 - Justin Lashley I can't ...rewrite... 5.5 Stars

#24 - kubilay kocaoglu musician 5.49 Stars

#25 - Süleyman Gürgün My Music Puff 5.48 Stars

#26 - Tomas Vega nobody`s perfect 5.42 Stars

#27 - hongman march 2008 entry 5.38 Stars

#28 - mark whitcombe unbelievable 5.33 Stars

#29 - Winnie . S I want to confess... 5.31 Stars

#30 - Chris Tan Its Never Perfect 5.25 Stars

#31 - vince gorman i'm emotional! 5.24 Stars

#32 - Guilherme Trog Perfect Music 5.23 Stars

#33 - Alan Starship I Kill You... 5.21 Stars

#34 - Vinay Kumar Disappointed Guy 5.16 Stars

#34 - Alan Camilo Alien Astronaut 5.16 Stars

#36 - gergely kali flawless 5.1 Stars

#36 - Jude Brownbill Drama 5.1 Stars

#36 - Jose Maria Ravalo The unhappy robot. 5.1 Stars

#39 - takashi yokoya I'm Mozart ! 5.09 Stars

#40 - Miran Dilberovic-Gelic Unfair 5.06 Stars

#41 - Dave Edwardz Unhappy Chappy 4.96 Stars

#42 - andrew keeble torn up! 4.95 Stars

#43 - Łukasz Burnet Unbelievable 4.91 Stars

#44 - Ezra Allen But Its Perfect as it is! 4.84 Stars

#44 - Carlos Fins Fustrated Artist 4.84 Stars

#46 - Brad Bradbury Feathered and Flawed 4.83 Stars

#47 - Yogesh Kaushal Elvis 4.82 Stars

#48 - Nate Lane Can't re-write whats perfect 4.75 Stars

#49 - chrisbyk It's unbelievable. 4.72 Stars

#50 - Gideon Caspi Frustrated Composer 4.7 Stars

#51 - Avner Engel The Ultimate Shutdown 4.66 Stars

#51 - Julien Abenhaim Moe Zart Surprise 4.66 Stars

#53 - Arthur Metcalf But it's perfect as it is 4.64 Stars

#53 - Tomas Jech Metro Music 4.64 Stars

#53 - Steve C When a man loves his music. 4.64 Stars

#56 - Andrew Farrell The Perfect Score 4.59 Stars

#57 - DIEGO COLLELL But it's perfect 4.58 Stars

#58 - Tony Mecca I hate that director... 4.55 Stars

#59 - Jean-Luc Delhougne The unbelievable final animation 4.53 Stars

#60 - Sergey B. Hopelessness . . . 4.51 Stars

#61 - Vahram Antonian Backstage Dilemna 4.49 Stars

#62 - peter adams un believable 4.47 Stars

#63 - Greg Wark I've been cut short 4.43 Stars

#64 - David Yarr Perfect as it is!! 4.41 Stars

#64 - Brad Kinley Sacked. 4.41 Stars

#66 - Jafar Perfect Music 4.32 Stars

#67 - Nino Stranger in a bus 4.31 Stars

#68 - Joanne Ku Perfect Music 4.3 Stars

#69 - Arron Westley "But it's perfect as it is" 4.27 Stars

#70 - sharad kumar frustration 4.26 Stars

#71 - Nick Hales Don't talk to the monkey... 4.25 Stars

#72 - eejun Unbelievable Schubert! 4.24 Stars

#73 - Dave Ward perfect music 4.23 Stars

#74 - David Andrade Mozart 4.22 Stars

#74 - Simon Hung Animator 4.22 Stars

#74 - German U. El Afina Maracas 4.22 Stars

#74 - John B Unbelivable! 4.22 Stars

#78 - Eric Huang It's not perfect... 4.21 Stars

#79 - Tom Law Perfect... 4.2 Stars

#80 - Kensaba Maestro 4.17 Stars

#81 - Giuseppe I can' t 4.16 Stars

#82 - Kenny perfect music 4.12 Stars

#83 - Louis Ng Perfect Ego 4.04 Stars

#84 - Jimmy Wu Unbelievable! 3.97 Stars

#85 - Arindam The Musician 3.96 Stars

#86 - Sarah Ricketts Music! 3.94 Stars

#86 - Chris Moss Perfect Music 3.94 Stars

#88 - Adriano Mariotto The Director 3.92 Stars

#89 - Lisa Tyler The Melodist and his Music 3.91 Stars

#90 - Robert Diaz March 11 Second Club 3.89 Stars

#91 - Ronaldo Brito Punk Singer 3.82 Stars

#92 - Hisato Tokumaru 60's 3.81 Stars

#93 - Drew Current Amadeus Ain't Playin'. Ya know? 3.75 Stars

#94 - Kim Allen artists love 3.72 Stars

#95 - Emmanuel I Can't... 3.71 Stars

#96 - Lawrence Tan Lithiumless 3.7 Stars

#97 - Dhar Unbelievable 3.65 Stars

#98 - Bussaba Techasrisutee it's perfect !! 3.64 Stars

#99 - Joey Ravioli Perfect 3.63 Stars

#100 - Kai Huai Overunbelievable 3.59 Stars

#101 - Frank Abney What's Perfect 3.58 Stars

#102 - Thiago Calçado JABÁ! 3.57 Stars

#102 - Nick Knudson Amadeus 3.57 Stars

#104 - bigesh tp perfect 3.56 Stars

#105 - Lukasz Kopec bad director 3.54 Stars

#106 - David Lochhead What's perfect.. 3.51 Stars

#107 - Paulo Cesar Biajante unbelievable 3.49 Stars

#108 - Rushikesh Joshi GAJJOSH_R.S.Joshi 3.44 Stars

#109 - sushant hard to believe...!! 3.4 Stars

#110 - Jarred de Beer Can't believe it! 3.36 Stars

#111 - Jeremie Rosner the lament 3.35 Stars

#112 - Pete Shand But it's perfect! 3.34 Stars

#112 - Ethan Reitz I cant rewrite 3.34 Stars

#114 - Shogna Chang Torn up my director!! 3.27 Stars

#115 - HIM CHAN ^_^ 3.25 Stars

#116 - Ryan Lowe It's perfect as it is... 3.21 Stars

#117 - Steve EmoBoy 3.19 Stars

#118 - Christoffer Andersen Composer can't believe it 3.18 Stars

#119 - James G. Petropoulos It's Unbelievable!!! 3.12 Stars

#120 - Brad Wright Plea to the Producers 3.11 Stars

#121 - rushang anxious 3.08 Stars

#122 - Renato Fochi Frustrated musician 3.03 Stars

#123 - prashant rawal rewrite whats perfect! 3.02 Stars

#123 - Bilal Ahmad the perfect writer 3.02 Stars

#125 - RaymondNg Rewrite!! 2.97 Stars

#126 - Michel Giguère Unbelievable 2.95 Stars

#127 - notapix-youtube ciceto wolfy 2.92 Stars

#128 - Tommy guitar zero 2.86 Stars

#129 - Matt Hubel Punk Composer 2.8 Stars

#130 - Jason Smith Perfection Has it's Price 2.78 Stars

#131 - Anthony Lynch Perfect 2.75 Stars

#132 - Dennis Jensen Snakes on boats 2.66 Stars

#132 - Jose Francisco Tarallo Awakening 2.66 Stars

#134 - Brad Regier Director's Call 2.61 Stars

#135 - Kuo Chung-kang Depressed Musician 2.58 Stars

#135 - Ungureanu Dragos cut 2.58 Stars

#135 - Brady Ritz A Mid-days Reflection on Life 2.58 Stars

#138 - Charles Blouin March 08 Unbelivable 2.5 Stars

#139 - Nico K I can't... rewrite what's perfec 2.48 Stars

#140 - Alec Sinanoski It's Perfect As It Is 2.37 Stars

#141 - Destinee Cleveland 11 second rant 2.3 Stars

#142 - eleazermunoz stand alone 2.25 Stars

#142 - dan tran amadeus 2.25 Stars

#144 - Gary Foster Torn Up 2.21 Stars

#145 - Mike Courtney March 2008 Entry 1.89 Stars

#146 - richard fox a bug's lament 1.87 Stars

#147 - Rory Perfect as it is? 1.86 Stars

#148 - Tom Steiner what is perfect 1.63 Stars