Corey McDaniel:

Very well done!

Darrell:

i like the animation could push it more, and i love the setting.. but it needs more of a story

colus havenga:

a good approach to the principal's office idea.

Chetan Jadhav:

good concept

Amdbcg:

pretty neat stuff :)

Matt Hirengen:

I love your staging, and the animation is very well executed. Great job!

Jeremy Schichtel:

nice staging

Juan Pablo:

I like the He has a gift :D

Alex Crouch:

Very nice performance, especially the son. Great staging, set design, lighting, and use of space in the scene.

Stefano:

the acting ideas are good but the body movements seems disconnected from the hands gestures. Some animation polishing will improve it a lot

Kim Allen:

creative piece of staging. really nice animation piece.

David Higgins:

I think you should have used a few camera cuts in there to improve it.

Paul Wei:

Really nice work!

Erik Griott:

very nice! you've established a clear relationship with the characters, both of them seem motivated, and their performances feel genuine! bravo!

Daniel Erwin:

i like the staging idea.

Timothy Yeo:

wow very good acting. subtle and powerful.
great job dood.

Kayum:

Nice staging and set-up. I really like the right-arm movement on frame 160

Nicolas Fourcroy:

Hi !!

It's the better camera framing in this contest !

Henk Kok:

Love the staging!

Ronny:

great atmosphere, the lightning its awesome, and the movements as well

David Jonson:

So good ~!

Rick Benz:

hand jesters seem out of place for scene, and who is he talking to?

deepak:

son character make the whole scene distracted . could've done lit bit cam pan towards the kid. animation is really good and the acting too. lipsing looks hard to read.

Renaud Déchaux:

Good animation but i don't understand why the character goes forward at the end of is dialogue.

Martin Silfvast:

good effort

Paul Fuller:

Nice staging and render. The man makes a sweep after "he has a gift" that isn't a directive sweep but more of a forget that kid sweep and its kind of confusing how he really feels about his kid.

rajeshk:

Nice animation but .. Son's action in FG is kinda distraction the viewer..

Raasi N:

both characters well animated..

Alejandro Perez:

Nice animation. I think that he may be overacting a little too much. The shot was interesting and the design of the background and lighting were nice too.

Chad Swanson:

Great Staging ! I like how ya started off with the characters both in the scene. However I would make a camera cut about frame 102 to show a closer up of the father talking. The action on the boy and him are both great but its distracting and hard to know who you should be looking at. Great job keep up the good work!

Frank G:

Interesting, stand out staging. The walking backward and forward conveys the father's restlessness nicely. Great effort!

jonas ekman:

i like the composition, but the downside is that it takes a bit too much attention away from the character in the background, great effort though!

Mark Homoky:

Nice reactions from the son as the father sounds more hopeful towards the end. Well done, and good luck!