Hernán Bruna:

Really good! but the quality of the video not so good, even well i give you a really good because the animation is great

Daniel Huertas:

i like the setting and the idea of the shot... but It can be polished a little bit more.... i also don't think the female character should be that happy saying her line at the end... .. keep it up

luc:

Like the concept. Not sure about HIS lip sync...like her though. Great job

Mike York:

Very cool staging

Tyson Ibele:

I thought the acting choices for this one were quite good...but the lip sync wasn't entirely convincing on the male character. Good work overall.

Erik Westlund:

concept for interaction is interesting but a bit of a stretch when considering what the "offering" is. Female seems kinda flirtatious for a "Mrs. Munchnick".

Emmanuel:

Interesting concept on how the girl is on the portrait. But the acting part of the guy is lacking.

Aaron Clement:

Not too bad... a little cliche at times.

Alex Fundora:

unique idea~ i especially like how it starts and ends into the picture stance. The shot where he says "yes" looks like to be a passionate gesture, though, i'm not buying why he shifts his eyes away from the picture. If it is because of mental anguish from.. perhaps.. losing the girl in the picture, then you should emphasize it by turning his head or drawing back his hand etc. Because right now it looks as though there is a bug or something that caught his attention instead of a feeling from the inside. Great animation.

V_I_C_K_Y:

This was my original stuff,
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=322504961104952788

Sunny Kharbanda:

Her exaggerated acting suits the scene setup you have... his acting is a little unclear.

Mariya Kalachova:

I don't really get the concept is my only criticism.

Taber Dunipace:

I think you missed the joke. Pretty good animation quality though. Acting is a bit odd; can't really tell what the guy is thinking.

Tim Nowak:

I like the twist on this one too. I really didnt expect this at all. Really nice animation skills

Mat Brady:

how can a picture give him a fruitcake? doesn't make sense. Good anim though.

Markus Kallio:

man needs work.

Matt Kenley:

ha, very odd idea, but I like it

HARISH:

excellent work !!! I really liked the idea very much ...........only one thing.. i felt the lip sync a bit off .

But .....very impressive overall

lizzie:

interesting set up

Ramit Batra:

Great concept!
And nice expressions on Mrs.Munchnik.
Good One!

jonathan topf:

best twist so far

Peter Carisi - de Lappe:

Interesting interpretation. Female's movements are very Animae-like. Gestures need work, but the overall concept is novel.

Joe Jacob:

I like the idea.

Dan Weiland:

Interesting concept! I like the idea with the whole picture thing. And I really like the acting from the female character. Good job!

cecile:

not the good intention

Ambuj:

wow nice flow!!

David Andrade:

Very intersting! Very intersting characters too. This has nothing to do with animation but.. his shadowing on him makes him look like he has a woman's chest ... I do like her gestures. He also has a nice pose at 285. I totally don't understand it though. He goes sad, so ok we can get the iea that she's dead (it took me two watches to see that.. maybe I'm slow :)

She's also very cheary. It's a lot of different attitudes in one sequence here and I don't think there's enough time to really gestitate the thought your presenting. She's happy he's sad. To me it feels like too much in one scene. It confused me.

I like her gestures but they don't feel connected to her because she's smiling throughout this whole thing. I don't really see a change in her emotion.

Be careful the plate pops in the beginning.

Roar Amundsen:

Nice animation. I don`t quite understand the hand gesture he does when sating "yes".

Senthilnathan D:

wow this is very nice

Dave H Shovlin:

This is a nifty idea. I really like this. But the animation might be a little too lively for the circumstances.

Dan Harriman:

The motion is good here. And some of the poses are excellent! However I didn't get that the whole attitude here was a soppy lovey-dovey interaction at first. Is he blowing a kiss at the start? If so, then making that action crystal clear would have been an excellent way to set the scene. And the soppier the better! Also I think the girl's actions from 306 to the end don't fit. They look contrived and overacted. Particularly her very last pose. Other wise the her pose on 300 and the way she initially looks at the fruitcake is excellent- so mushy! And I like the look of the guys face when he says "Mrs Munchnik"